Exploring Dissent: The Cracks in the System

Understanding Dissent and Dissensus

Throughout history, there have been numerous instances where the power of dissent has been demonstrated. This unique human ability to express strong disagreement with various aspects of the political, social, or cultural status quo has sometimes led to revolutionary conflict. The concept of 'dissent' is closely linked to the term 'dissensus', as used by philosopher Jacques Rancière. He suggests that the essence of politics is dissensus, which he defines as the demonstration of a gap in the sensible itself. This means that political demonstration makes visible that which had no reason to be seen; it introduces one world into another.

The Role of Dissent in Modern Politics

In today's political climate, particularly in the United States, there is a forced 'consensus' brought about by the ruling party and its figureheads. This structures the 'sensible' world of perception in such a way that any deviation from 'accepted' ways of acting is met with disapproval and outrage. However, dissensus, according to Rancière, is the 'essence of politics' as it demonstrates that no existing political dispensation is ever saturated and devoid of other political possibilities. Therefore, those who are aware of their capacity for dissensus are called upon to stage its 'scenes', creating 'gaps' in the regime of the sensible.

Historical Instances of Dissent

Throughout human history, the power of dissent has been demonstrated in numerous ways. From the slave revolt led by Spartacus against Rome to the French and American revolutions, dissent has been at the heart of major historical events. Other instances include the American Civil War, which was rooted in Northern dissent surrounding the practice of slavery, and Martin Luther's dissent against malpractices within the Roman Catholic Church, which gave rise to a different kind of religion within Christian ranks.

Dissent in Various Forms

Dissent is not always publicly conspicuous; it can manifest itself in households on a daily basis. For instance, subordinated women often engage in dissent against the oppression or abuse they experience. In excessively patriarchal countries, dissent can take many forms, such as a woman openly driving a car as a demonstration of independence. Dissent is ubiquitous and everyone who reflects on this would probably be able to pinpoint a manifestation of it in their own lives.

The Value of Dissent

John Fowles, one of the most celebrated novelists of the 20th century, offered a thoughtful reflection on the seldom acknowledged value of dissent. He suggested that dissent is a universal human phenomenon and is needed always, especially in our own age. In his novel, A Maggot, Fowles explores the concept of dissent through the character of Ann Lee, a female religious leader at a time when women were still regarded as naturally and constitutionally inferior to men. Her dissent, and that of the Shakers, can be gauged from their rejection of sexual intercourse between men and women, including husband and wife.

Relevance of Dissent Today

Fowles's exploration of dissent is particularly relevant today. In the face of mainstream media manipulation and disinformation, those who do not avail themselves of alternative news and commentary sources face a constant barrage of distorted information. In this context, dissent becomes a refusal to believe what those in power would have us believe.

Bottom Line

Dissent, in its many forms, is a crucial aspect of human society. It challenges the status quo, introduces new perspectives, and can lead to revolutionary change. However, it's also a concept that is often misunderstood or overlooked. What are your thoughts on the role of dissent in society? Do you see its value, or do you believe it causes more harm than good? Share this article with your friends and discuss. Don't forget to sign up for the Daily Briefing, every day at 6pm.