Reflection on BBC News Coverage of a Murder Case
Initial Reactions to the News Report
On August 29th, BBC News At Ten reported about the conviction of a murderer who took the life of a 15-year-old girl in a town in the northeast of England. The report included graphic details about the crime, including the number of times the victim was stabbed and the fact that the knife used in the attack had broken during the incident. An image of the weapon was also shown. While the crime was undoubtedly horrific, it wasn't immediately clear why it was the leading story on the state broadcaster's flagship news program. There was no mention of a failure in policing or social care, or any other factor of broader public interest.
Questioning the BBC's Intentions
This led to questions about whether the BBC was resorting to the sensationalism often associated with tabloid journalism, or if there was a more targeted campaign to demoralize its audience. Amid the gruesome details, the report mentioned that the killer had been diagnosed with autism. This seemed to imply that the report was not merely sensationalist, but also aimed to instill a sense of hopelessness and helplessness in its audience.
Implications for Families with Autistic Children
Autism is a condition diagnosed in one in 100 children in the UK. It is characterized by a spectrum of symptoms and uncertain outcomes. The report may have caused anxiety in many households with autistic children, as it could have led parents to fear that their child might one day commit a similar act.
Transhumanism and the Labeling of Autism
Transhumanism is often discussed in terms of technology, but it can also apply to the labels we apply to ourselves and our children. Once a child has been diagnosed with autism, certain behaviors may become accepted, even if they prevent the child from fully participating in society. The label of autism can also undermine a parent's confidence in their ability to shape their child's future.
The Importance of Moral Formation
In today's society, moral formation is often taught through abstract principles and the promotion of "kindness." However, neither of these methods is a sound foundation for moral life. Abstract principles are open to interpretation, and feelings like kindness can be unreliable.
Preparing Autistic Children for Moral Life
Children with autism can struggle with abstract principles and may not respond to sentiment in the same way as other children. However, they can learn to be good people through practice, forming good habits, and following good examples.
Defying the BBC's Agenda
In response to the BBC's report, parents of children with autism should reject the labels that can lead to feelings of helplessness. Instead, they should focus on forming habits with their child and setting a good example.
Anecdote from Temple Grandin
Temple Grandin, author of The Autistic Brain, once responded to a parent's question about whether their autistic child cared about them by saying, "If your house is on fire, they will help you to get out." This simple statement highlights the potential for autistic individuals to demonstrate goodness through actions rather than words or feelings.
Bottom Line
The way the media reports on crimes committed by individuals with autism can have a profound impact on public perception of the condition. It's important to remember that individuals with autism, like all people, are capable of moral behavior and can learn to be good people through practice and example. What are your thoughts on this issue? Share this article with your friends and consider signing up for the Daily Briefing, which is delivered every day at 6pm.
